24-Apr-2024 22:26 GMT.
UNDER CONSTRUCTION
[News] Transcript of Alan Redhouses speech at AmiGBG 2003ANN.lu
Posted on 31-Mar-2003 19:40 GMT by Peter Gordon54 comments
View flat
View list
I have transcribed Alans AmiGBG speech. It can be viewed here.
List of all comments to this article
Sorted by date, most recent at bottom
Comment 1Ole-Egil31-Mar-2003 18:04 GMT
Comment 2Ole-Egil31-Mar-2003 18:07 GMT
Comment 3Ole-Egil31-Mar-2003 18:10 GMT
Comment 4Ole-Egil31-Mar-2003 18:12 GMT
Comment 5Peter Gordon31-Mar-2003 18:25 GMT
Comment 6SlimJim31-Mar-2003 18:40 GMT
Comment 7SlimJim31-Mar-2003 18:45 GMT
Comment 8SlimJim31-Mar-2003 18:54 GMT
Comment 9Ole-Egil31-Mar-2003 19:02 GMT
Comment 10Peter Gordon31-Mar-2003 19:13 GMT
Comment 11James Carroll31-Mar-2003 22:48 GMT
Comment 12Atheist231-Mar-2003 23:50 GMT
Transcript of Alan Redhouses speech at AmiGBG 2003 : Comment 13 of 54ANN.lu
Posted by Anonymous on 01-Apr-2003 01:39 GMT
Great transcript, thank you very much for the effort!

What did Alan mean with just 3% speed gain through L3 cache?
On Macs it makes quite a difference and games (Hyperion!) like Quake3 benefit
greatly from it. Some examples of iMac 1GHz w/o L3 cache vs. PowerMac 1GHz with
(just) 1MB L3 cache [c´t 6/2003 page 108]:

Cinebench 2001
Shading (C4D): 7.44 vs. 8.08
Shading (OpenGL): 9 vs. 9.79

Photoshop 7
Action 1: 23s vs. 20s
Action 2: 48s vs. 42s

iTunes
MP3 encoding: 5min48s vs. 4min40s

Quake3
Demo Four 68: 67.7fps vs. 82.9fps

Quicktime
Sorenson 2: 3min vs. 2min47s
Sorenson 3: 1min16s vs. 1min09

Both had the same gfxcard (GF4MX 64MB DDR) and memory subsystem (PC2100).

http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/G4CARDS/giga_designs_800_1ghz/index.html shows
that L3 cache can make an average difference of well over 10% (please also
notice the extreme Q3 and UT results...).
http://macspeedzone.com/ ist another source for comparative numbers.
http://www.powerlogix.com/downloads/SDRDDR.pdf comes to the following conclusion: "Clearly it is important to have some sort of L3 cache, but the type and
speed of the L3 are almost irrelevant. In fact, the only factor that matters to any degree, is
L3 cache size, and even that is not a huge difference"

So _if_ Alan only gets 3% performance gain from L3 cache there must be something
wrong with AmigaOne - also the G4 working only up to 40 degrees sounds like a
joke since the CPUs are specified for at least 65 degrees operation.
Jump...
#14 reflect #15 Ole-Egil #16 Ole-Egil #18 alan buxey #19 steffo / cryonics
TopPrevious commentNext commentbottom
List of all comments to this article (continued)
Comment 14reflect01-Apr-2003 06:00 GMT
Comment 15Ole-Egil01-Apr-2003 06:44 GMT
Comment 16Ole-Egil01-Apr-2003 06:46 GMT
Comment 17Jim Forbes-Ritte (AGAfaster)01-Apr-2003 07:16 GMT
Comment 18alan buxey01-Apr-2003 08:33 GMT
Comment 19steffo / cryonics01-Apr-2003 09:31 GMT
Comment 20Anonymous01-Apr-2003 09:40 GMT
Comment 21Ole-Egil01-Apr-2003 09:45 GMT
Comment 22Anonymous01-Apr-2003 11:05 GMT
Comment 23Don Cox01-Apr-2003 11:20 GMT
Comment 24Jim Forbes-Ritte (AGAfaster)01-Apr-2003 11:53 GMT
Comment 25Ole-Egil01-Apr-2003 12:48 GMT
Comment 26Ole-Egil01-Apr-2003 12:49 GMT
Comment 27SlimJim01-Apr-2003 16:12 GMT
Comment 28Anonymous01-Apr-2003 19:09 GMT
Comment 29Anonymous01-Apr-2003 19:20 GMT
Comment 30Anonymous01-Apr-2003 19:28 GMT
Comment 31David Scheibler01-Apr-2003 22:03 GMT
Comment 32StormLord01-Apr-2003 22:05 GMT
Comment 33Anonymous02-Apr-2003 03:50 GMT
Comment 34Ole-Egil02-Apr-2003 06:18 GMT
Comment 35samface02-Apr-2003 07:35 GMT
Comment 36IanG02-Apr-2003 10:10 GMT
Comment 37David Scheibler02-Apr-2003 10:17 GMT
Comment 38Anonymous02-Apr-2003 10:41 GMT
Comment 39Anonymous02-Apr-2003 11:21 GMT
Comment 40IanG02-Apr-2003 14:30 GMT
Comment 41IanG02-Apr-2003 14:41 GMT
Comment 42Anonymous02-Apr-2003 16:03 GMT
Comment 43Peter Gordon02-Apr-2003 16:23 GMT
Comment 44Anonymous02-Apr-2003 16:33 GMT
Comment 45Peter Gordon02-Apr-2003 19:11 GMT
Comment 46Bill "tekmage" Borsari02-Apr-2003 19:26 GMT
Comment 47Zorro03-Apr-2003 09:31 GMT
Comment 48IanG03-Apr-2003 10:10 GMT
Comment 49Ole-Egil03-Apr-2003 10:41 GMT
Comment 50Anonymous03-Apr-2003 12:47 GMT
Comment 51IanG03-Apr-2003 14:14 GMT
Comment 52Sigbjørn Skjæret03-Apr-2003 17:38 GMT
Comment 53Darth_X03-Apr-2003 18:48 GMT
Comment 54Jim Forbes-Ritte (AGAfaster)04-Apr-2003 05:20 GMT
Back to Top