27-Nov-2020 00:02 GMT.
UNDER CONSTRUCTION
[Forum] Internet TV patentANN.lu
Posted on 17-Jul-2004 09:33 GMT by Amon_Re62 comments
View flat
View list
Yet another software patent that shouldn't have been granted :( See here
List of all comments to this article
Sorted by date, most recent at bottom
Comment 1Kolbjørn Barmen17-Jul-2004 10:14 GMT
Comment 2Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 10:38 GMT
Comment 3NekoRegistered user17-Jul-2004 10:43 GMT
Comment 4Fabio AlemagnaRegistered user17-Jul-2004 10:45 GMT
Comment 5Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 12:20 GMT
Comment 6NekoRegistered user17-Jul-2004 12:22 GMT
Comment 7Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 12:24 GMT
Comment 8Fabio AlemagnaRegistered user17-Jul-2004 12:24 GMT
Comment 9Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 12:25 GMT
Comment 10Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 12:26 GMT
Comment 11Bill Toner17-Jul-2004 13:24 GMT
Comment 12Andrew Korn17-Jul-2004 13:25 GMT
Comment 13Joe "Floid" Kanowitz17-Jul-2004 13:29 GMT
Comment 14Don CoxRegistered user17-Jul-2004 14:06 GMT
Comment 15Rafo17-Jul-2004 15:07 GMT
Comment 16Fabio AlemagnaRegistered user17-Jul-2004 15:11 GMT
Comment 17Bill Hoggett17-Jul-2004 15:43 GMT
Comment 18Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 15:44 GMT
Comment 19NekoRegistered user17-Jul-2004 17:45 GMT
Comment 20Fabio AlemagnaRegistered user17-Jul-2004 18:00 GMT
Comment 21Bill Hoggett17-Jul-2004 19:09 GMT
Comment 22Amon_ReRegistered user17-Jul-2004 20:44 GMT
Comment 23Kolbjørn Barmen17-Jul-2004 22:56 GMT
Comment 24Darrin18-Jul-2004 02:52 GMT
Comment 25Kronos18-Jul-2004 04:45 GMT
Comment 26Darrin18-Jul-2004 05:11 GMT
Comment 27Amon_ReRegistered user18-Jul-2004 06:16 GMT
Comment 28Amon_ReRegistered user18-Jul-2004 06:28 GMT
Comment 29Darrin18-Jul-2004 07:22 GMT
Comment 30Darrin18-Jul-2004 07:40 GMT
Comment 31Amon_ReRegistered user18-Jul-2004 08:23 GMT
Comment 32Kolbjørn Barmen18-Jul-2004 08:34 GMT
Comment 33Amon_ReRegistered user18-Jul-2004 08:38 GMT
Comment 34Kolbjørn Barmen18-Jul-2004 08:59 GMT
Comment 35Darrin18-Jul-2004 09:17 GMT
Comment 36Darrin18-Jul-2004 09:19 GMT
Comment 37Kolbjørn Barmen18-Jul-2004 09:25 GMT
Internet TV patent : Comment 38 of 62ANN.lu
Posted by Darrin on 18-Jul-2004 09:46 GMT
In reply to Comment 33 (Amon_Re):
>GIFS, however, are a data format, and patenting a way to save data to a
>magnetic storage medium are things wich should never be patented, as they
>conflict with the right of the author to use his data as he pleases.

But the data doesn't have to be stored as a GIF. The data can be stored in another format. If I decide to store data as a GIF then it's my fault.

>Then where would you draw the line?

Tough question and I don't know.

>We don't know yet, because they aren't valid all over the world, what if
>tomorrow the EU accepts software patents, and IBM or British Telecom or
>whomever desides to use their patents to sue their competitors to the ground?

We don't know... exactly. I doubt that BT will be able to sue anyone over something that wasn't illegal at the time. If the US government makes drinking tea illegal today then I'm not going to get jailed over the cup that I drank yesterday.

> Or worse, say you create an app that implements a way to store files, and
> some big corporation thinks you are abusing their patent (of wich you had no
> prior knowledge) and starts sueing you for x amount of damages?

If you had no prior knowledge then you're probably going to get away with it. Perhaps the big corporation will grant you a license.

Mind you, if you had tried to patent it as well then you'd have found out that someone beat you too it. ;-)

>It would kill the small companies, hobby programmers, and in the end, probably
> also linux

No, you can program things using code that doesn't have patent restrictions or that has ahd the patent run out. This should be fine for Linux as it's about 15 years behind Windoze and all Linux users wear tank-tops and bell-bottom trousers!!!! <that was a joke!!!>.

>Wich means the Amiga wouldn't be possible, untill somewhere arround 1990, same
> for Apple, Atari & Microsoft,

It could have been licensed, or all of those excellent games could have been coded to run from the CLI and use a joystick only.

>And do you know the costs involved in defending a patent? For starters, the
>lawyer fees? Believe me, the small man in the street will be screwed left
> right infront & behind by big corporations

Or you would have an army of lawyers offering their services for free in order to get 50% of the huge settlement they're going to win you.

>The law has actually nothing to do with it, it's more a principle thing,
>besides, i like shiny boxes :P

:-)

>Yes, because i happen to run linux quite alot, it's my main os, infact,
>there's no DVD player installed in the windows partition i have

no DVD drive either? I can hear Bill Gates crying from here ;-)

>You very well know i was refurring to "fair use"

I know. And you know I know. And I know that you know that I know. ;-)

>For you, perhaps, for me, it's a violation of my rights (fair use)

You have some strange ideas on what a "violation" is. ;-)

>I'm pretty sure she would agree with me :P

LOL. And that's the scary part!!! :-)
Jump...
#40 Amon_Re
TopPrevious commentNext commentbottom
List of all comments to this article (continued)
Comment 39Amon_ReRegistered user18-Jul-2004 09:51 GMT
Comment 40Amon_ReRegistered user18-Jul-2004 09:57 GMT
Comment 41Darrin18-Jul-2004 09:57 GMT
Comment 42Darrin18-Jul-2004 09:59 GMT
Comment 43Darrin18-Jul-2004 10:01 GMT
Comment 443seas18-Jul-2004 11:09 GMT
Comment 45Darrin18-Jul-2004 11:29 GMT
Comment 46RAG18-Jul-2004 11:59 GMT
Comment 47Darrin18-Jul-2004 13:02 GMT
Comment 48mark18-Jul-2004 20:40 GMT
Comment 49Olegil19-Jul-2004 08:50 GMT
Comment 50ujb19-Jul-2004 13:43 GMT
Comment 51Darrin19-Jul-2004 14:23 GMT
Comment 52Darrin19-Jul-2004 14:40 GMT
Comment 53Fabio AlemagnaRegistered user19-Jul-2004 15:48 GMT
Comment 54Darrin19-Jul-2004 16:14 GMT
Comment 55Amon_ReRegistered user19-Jul-2004 20:03 GMT
Comment 56Amon_ReRegistered user19-Jul-2004 20:07 GMT
Comment 57ujb20-Jul-2004 06:38 GMT
Comment 58RAG20-Jul-2004 09:04 GMT
Comment 59Amon_ReRegistered user20-Jul-2004 10:10 GMT
Comment 60Darth_XRegistered user21-Jul-2004 22:18 GMT
Comment 61Darth_XRegistered user21-Jul-2004 22:23 GMT
Comment 62Darth_XRegistered user21-Jul-2004 22:38 GMT
Back to Top